Blog scientist
Oceans on brink of mass extinction: study
Brain exercises delay mental decline
Meaning of life changes across cosmos
Ancient Nubians drank antibiotic beer
First mission to touch the Sun
There's gold in them thar bacteria!
Low vitamin D linked to schizophrenia
Weight loss may be toxic: study
Pilbara find points to earliest life
Researchers uncover dance moves to impress
Visual trickery key to luring lover
Scientists find short-sightedness gene
Artificial 'skin' can sense pressure
Study confirms antibiotics mess with gut
Phone chatter could power mobiles
Stowaways found hitching ride on seaweed
Fishing could feed millions more: report
Amateurs make an astronomical impact
Study reveals new piece in autism puzzle
Genome map may help devil fight cancer
Report says ozone layer depletion stopped
Moon's surface at saturation point
Gene sweeps nets female cancer clues
Australia birthplace of astronomy: study
Organ consent needs thought transplant
Arguments about whether organ donor systems should be based on presumed consent are missing the point when it comes to increasing donation rates, says a leading UK clinical scientist.

In a paper published today in the British Medical Journal, Professor John Fabre of the School of Medicine, Kings College London examines Spain's organ donor system against that in the United Kingdom.

Spain has the world's highest rate of deceased organ donation, two and a half times higher than in the UK.

Fabre says that Spain's excellent record on organ donation does not depend on its 'presumed consent', or 'opt-out', legislation, which was introduced in 1979. He argues that a donor's family is always asked for consent, and that the family's wishes are final.

In the United Kingdom, which has an 'opt-in' organ donor policy, there is a refusal rate of about 40%. Refusal rate is a measure of the percentage of families of eligible potential donors who refuse to make the organs available. Spain's refusal rate is about 15%, while in Australia the rate is similar to the UK.

Gerry O'Callaghan, National Medical Director of the Australian Organ and Tissue Authority, known as Donate Life, says Spain has achieved that not because of presumed consent, but because they concentrated on society's attitudes.

"Organ donation has become a routine part of the conversation around end-of-life care in Spanish hospitals", he says. "Over the course of the last twenty years they have trained thousands of doctors and nurses about the benefits in a medical sense, improved quality of life, the improved mortality rates in transplant recipients."

The paper in the British Medical Journal says, in 1989 donation rates in Spain and the UK were both about 14 per million population. That represents a refusal rate between 30% and 40%. In Spain that figure changed dramatically after the country introduced a comprehensive, national organ donation campaign.

In the 12 years since, Spain's refusal rate fell by more than half, while Britain's has remained high.
Intensive care rethink?

Fabre also puts the difference down to Britain's low provision of intensive care beds, about 27 per million population, compared to more than 87 in Spain.

He argues, doctors in the UK are less likely to allocate an intensive care bed to a patient with a poor prognosis. They are also more likely to stop life support before brain stem death.

O'Callaghan says the Australian transplant rate is improving, but agrees that the number of available intensive care positions makes a crucial difference.

"That is an important point about whether or not the clinical resources are available in order to provide life support to individuals in these situations," he says. "I think that's a much more insightful point about why donation rates are different in England and Australia or Spain."

Chris Thomas of Transplant Australia says the issue of intensive care beds needs to addressed.

"That's something that I don't think Australian regulators have fully examined", he says.

"There's huge pressure on intensive care beds and when a doctor is left with the crucial decision of whether to keep an intensive care bed occupied by a potential donor while the family makes a decision, or vacate that bed for the next injured person coming in, that decision is crystal clear.

"It would be worthy of a study of whether or not that's putting an artificial ceiling on donation rates."

Census charts world beneath the seas
Wonder carbon nets pair Nobel Physics Prize
Focus on chest for CPR: study
Bull ants have right eye for the job
Carbon chemistry pioneers share prize
Ancient galaxies found in modern universe
Solar surprise for climate models
Study predicts end of world as we know it
Rare plant has biggest genome yet found
Astronomers find long-lost lunar rover
Flight paths may be bad for the heart
Complex Haitian quake triggered tsunamis
US doctors usher in 'dawn of stem cell age'
Changing demographics impact CO2 levels
Sleeping in lit room leads to weight gain
Harsh conditions create sterile workers
Study finds pigeons love a flutter
Humpback whale beats long-distance record
Survey to dive deep into Australian waters
Bad jobs affect mental health
Hubble captures suspected asteroid crash
Mysterious pulsar has astronomers in a spin
Native rice may hold key to food future
Future LEDs may be what the doctor orders
Bilingualism good for the brain
Organ consent needs thought transplant
Cavemen ground flour, prepped veggies
Fossilised iceblocks shed light on early life
Water on Moon bad news for astronomy
Human eye evolved to see dark world
Wind could have parted sea for Moses
CERN scientists spot potential discovery
Malaria crossed to humans from gorillas
Horny find uncovers Triceratops' predecessor
Time passes quicker for high flyers
Da Vinci's ornithopter takes flight
Software smart bomb aimed at Iran: experts
High oestrogen levels may impact brain
Quantum leap towards computer of the future
Study finds predictive power of search
Cardio routine can nurture sweet dreams
Restored Apollo 11 footage to be screened
'Extinct' animals back from the dead
Astronomers find home away from home
Study locates our sense of direction
Records reveal First Fleet's wet welcome
Dinosaurs taller thanks to thick cartilage
Free mammograms 'should start at 40'
Grunting slows opponent's reaction time
Colour preferences shaped by experience
Father of IVF wins Nobel prize
Happiness more than gene deep
Visit Statistics